Skip to content
Chuckwagon & Ember
A slice of golden custard pie with a caramelized top

Pictured: buttermilk chess pie, a close cousin of vinegar pie. Photo: “Buttermilk Chess Pie, August 2009” by Kimberly Vardeman, CC BY 2.0. Resized and converted to WebP.

Home ovenDutch oven

Vinegar Pie

A "desperation pie" that tastes like lemon chess

The Trail Story

When there were no lemons for a hundred miles, cooks made do. Vinegar pie belongs to a family of "desperation pies" from the 1800s that used pantry staples to stand in for fresh fruit. A splash of vinegar gave the tang, and sugar and fat did the rest.

Eggs were scarce on the trail, and some old recipes thicken the filling with flour alone, which is how our trail version works. The modern version adds eggs and butter for a silky custard that surprises almost everyone who tries it.

Time
15 min prep · 50 min cook
Serves
8 · 9 ingredients
Difficulty
Easy
Heat
350°F oven

Unlock the full cookbook

Get all 9 ingredients and step-by-step instructions for Vinegar Pie, in both the trail original and the modern kitchen version, plus every other recipe in the book.

The Cookbook

$9.44

One-time payment · yours for good

Trail Membership

$6.99/month

Cookbook + new recipes & stories monthly

Membership: Renews at $6.99/month. Cancel anytime from your account.

Already bought it? Sign in